The Area of Freedom, Security and Justice (AFSJ) is one of the EU's most dynamic policy areas. It covers the free movement of persons, asylum, immigration, border controls, judicial cooperation in civil and criminal matters, and police cooperation. The legal basis is Art. 67–89 TFEU (Title V). It replaces the old third-pillar structure abolished by the Lisbon Treaty.
1. The Three Dimensions of the AFSJ
🕊️
Freedom
Free movement of persons. Abolition of internal border controls (Schengen). Rights of EU citizens abroad. Asylum and migration rules. Visa policy.
ART. 77–80 TFEU
🛡️
Security
Police cooperation (Europol). Counter-terrorism. Organised crime. Drug trafficking. Cross-border crime. Operational cooperation between law enforcement agencies.
ART. 87–89 TFEU
⚖️
Justice
Judicial cooperation in civil and criminal matters. Mutual recognition of judgments and decisions. Eurojust (prosecutorial cooperation). EU criminal law harmonisation.
ART. 81–86 TFEU
Shared competence & special rules: AFSJ is a shared competence (Art. 4 TFEU). It uses mostly QMV (Qualified Majority Voting) + co-decision (OLP). However, some sensitive areas (e.g. operational police cooperation, family law) require unanimity. Denmark and Ireland have special opt-in/opt-out protocols, making the AFSJ a differentiated integration area.
2. Schengen Area & Border Controls
The Schengen Agreement (1985) and Schengen Convention (1990) created an area without internal border controls. It was incorporated into EU law by the Amsterdam Treaty (1999). Today it is governed by the Schengen Borders Code (Regulation 2016/399).
🇦🇹 Austria
🇧🇪 Belgium
🇧🇬 Bulgaria*
🇭🇷 Croatia
🇨🇿 Czechia
🇩🇰 Denmark
🇪🇪 Estonia
🇫🇮 Finland
🇫🇷 France
🇩🇪 Germany
🇬🇷 Greece
🇭🇺 Hungary
🇮🇸 Iceland†
🇮🇹 Italy
🇱🇻 Latvia
🇱🇮 Liecht.†
🇱🇹 Lithuania
🇱🇺 Luxembourg
🇲🇹 Malta
🇳🇱 Netherlands
🇳🇴 Norway†
🇵🇱 Poland
🇵🇹 Portugal
🇷🇴 Romania*
🇸🇰 Slovakia
🇸🇮 Slovenia
🇪🇸 Spain
🇸🇪 Sweden
🇨🇭 Switz.†
† Non-EU Schengen members (Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Switzerland). · *Romania & Bulgaria: air/sea Schengen from March 2024; full land border integration from January 2025. · 🇮🇪 Ireland and 🇨🇾 Cyprus are EU members NOT in Schengen.
Temporary reintroduction of border controls: Under Art. 25–35 Schengen Borders Code, member states may temporarily reintroduce internal border checks for up to 30 days (renewable, max 2 years) for serious public order or security threats. Several member states have used this provision repeatedly (e.g. France, Germany, Austria).
SIS II — Schengen Information System: Shared database for alerts on persons and objects (wanted persons, missing persons, banned persons, lost/stolen documents). Used by border guards, police, and customs authorities across the Schengen area.
3. Asylum & Migration Policy
Legal basis: Art. 78–79 TFEU. The EU has built a Common European Asylum System (CEAS). The EU's competence is shared with member states. The principle of solidarity (Art. 80 TFEU) requires burden-sharing between member states — a politically contentious issue.
Common European Asylum System (CEAS)
Key CEAS Instruments
Dublin Regulation (Regulation 604/2013)
Determines which EU member state is responsible for processing an asylum application. General rule: country of first entry. Widely criticised for placing burden on frontline states (Greece, Italy).
Asylum Procedures Directive / Regulation
Harmonises how member states process asylum claims — common standards for examining applications, appeals, legal aid, and accelerated procedures at borders.
Qualification Directive / Regulation
Defines who qualifies for refugee status (1951 Geneva Convention) or subsidiary protection. Harmonises rights granted: residence permit, work access, social welfare.
Reception Conditions Directive
Sets minimum standards for reception of asylum seekers: housing, food, healthcare, education for children, employment access. Prevents "race to the bottom" among member states.
New Pact on Migration and Asylum (2024)
Comprehensive reform package agreed after years of deadlock. Introduces mandatory solidarity mechanism (relocation or financial contribution), faster border screening, new Asylum and Migration Management Regulation replacing Dublin.
4. Key AFSJ Agencies
Europol
European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Cooperation
📍 The Hague, Netherlands
Supports member states in fighting serious cross-border crime and terrorism. Facilitates information exchange, provides analysis, coordinates joint operations. No executive/arrest powers — purely supportive.
Eurojust
European Union Agency for Criminal Justice Cooperation
📍 The Hague, Netherlands
Coordinates cross-border criminal prosecutions between member state judicial authorities. Can request member states to investigate or prosecute. Art. 85 TFEU allows regulations to grant Eurojust further powers.
Frontex
European Border and Coast Guard Agency
📍 Warsaw, Poland
Supports member states in managing external borders and combating irregular migration. Has a standing corps of border guards (10,000 by 2027). Conducts return operations. Greatly expanded after 2015 migration crisis.
EUAA
EU Agency for Asylum (formerly EASO)
📍 Valletta, Malta
Supports member states in implementing the CEAS. Provides operational and technical assistance, trains asylum officials, produces country of origin information (COI) reports. Renamed from EASO to EUAA in 2022 with expanded mandate.
5. Judicial Cooperation & Mutual Recognition
A cornerstone of AFSJ is the principle of mutual recognition of judicial decisions — court decisions in one member state are recognised and enforced in others without reopening proceedings.
Mutual Recognition in Practice
Art. 82 TFEU establishes mutual recognition as the basis for judicial cooperation in criminal matters. Art. 81 TFEU does the same for civil matters.
🔑 European Arrest Warrant (EAW)
Framework Decision 2002/584/JHA. Replaces extradition between member states with a simplified surrender procedure. Issued by a judicial authority; executed in 10–60 days. Most significant AFSJ instrument in practice.
💰 European Investigation Order
Directive 2014/41/EU. A judicial decision requiring another member state to gather specific evidence for criminal proceedings. Covers obtaining bank records, intercepts, witness statements.
⚖️ European Enforcement Order
Regulation 805/2004. Allows enforcement of uncontested civil/commercial judgment claims across the EU without a separate recognition procedure ("exequatur").
🏛️ EPPO (European Public Prosecutor's Office)
European Public Prosecutor's Office — established 2021 via enhanced cooperation (22 member states). Investigates and prosecutes crimes against EU's financial interests (fraud, money laundering). Based in Luxembourg.
6. Opt-Out Protocols: Denmark & Ireland
🇩🇰
Denmark — Full Opt-Out
Protocol 22 to the Treaties. Denmark does not participate in AFSJ measures (including Schengen-building measures within EU law, though it applies Schengen via an intergovernmental agreement). It can choose to opt in to specific measures but is not automatically bound. After a 2022 referendum, Denmark opted back into Europol full membership.
🇮🇪
Ireland — Selective Opt-In
Protocol 21. Ireland is not bound by AFSJ measures by default but may opt in to specific measures (before or after adoption). Ireland participates in parts of the CEAS and some criminal justice instruments. Ireland is not in Schengen (maintains Common Travel Area with the UK).
Key Terms
AFSJ
Area of Freedom, Security and Justice — Art. 67–89 TFEU; covers Schengen, asylum, migration, police and judicial cooperation.
Schengen Area
29-country zone without internal border controls; governed by Schengen Borders Code; includes 4 non-EU members.
Dublin Regulation
Determines which EU state is responsible for an asylum claim — generally the country of first entry.
CEAS
Common European Asylum System — harmonised rules for asylum procedures, qualification, reception conditions, and responsibility allocation.
Europol
EU law enforcement cooperation agency (The Hague); supports fight against serious cross-border crime; no arrest powers.
European Arrest Warrant
Simplified cross-border surrender mechanism based on mutual recognition; replaces extradition between member states since 2004.
EPPO
European Public Prosecutor's Office — investigates crimes against EU financial interests; 22 participating states; based in Luxembourg.
Frontex
EU border and coast guard agency (Warsaw); manages external borders; standing corps of up to 10,000 guards; conducts return operations.
Question 1
What is the legal basis in the TFEU for the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice?
A) Art. 39–44 TFEU
B) Art. 67–89 TFEU
C) Art. 119–144 TFEU
D) Art. 174–178 TFEU
✓ Correct Answer: B — Title V TFEU (Art. 67–89) covers the AFSJ. Art. 39–44 = CAP (Common Agricultural Policy); Art. 119–144 = EMU (Economic and Monetary Union); Art. 174–178 = Cohesion Policy.
Question 2
How many countries are in the Schengen Area as of 2025?
✓ Correct Answer: D — As of January 2025 (Romania & Bulgaria's land borders fully integrated), the Schengen Area has 29 members: 25 EU member states + Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein, and Switzerland. Cyprus and Ireland are EU members outside Schengen.
Ready to Test Your Knowledge?
Start Practising on EPSOready →
Practice 1,500+ EPSO-style questions across all 5 test categories — including EU & Digital Knowledge, Verbal, Numerical, Abstract reasoning.